Coinbase Attorney Claims Gary Gensler’s Email is Crucial Evidence in SEC Lawsuit

The legal battle between Coinbase and the SEC heated up on July 3 as the cryptocurrency exchange sought to gain access to emails from SEC Chair Gary Gensler, claiming they held crucial evidence for its defense.

Insights into Gensler’s Email Information Requests

In a July 3 letter to U.S. District Judge Katherine Failla

, Coinbase’s legal counsel argued that obtaining discovery from Gensler’s email is crucial to the company’s defense.

Coinbase’s attorneys argued that Gensler’s communication and views on cryptocurrencies as SEC Chair are crucial to Coinbase’s fair notice trial.

The legal team representing Coinbase argued:

“To determine whether this action comports with fair notice, the Court must consider whether a “person of ordinary intelligence” in Coinbase’s position had “a reasonable opportunity to know” what the securities laws and those charged with their enforcement prohibit with respect to secondary sales of digital assets — or, instead, whether “substantial uncertainty” deprived Coinbase of fair notice.”

This argument underscores Coinbase’s contention that understanding Gensler’s perspective and communications as SEC chair is essential in evaluating the fairness of the Coinbase SEC lawsuit.

The SEC filed charges against Coinbase in June 2023, alleging that the company operated as an unregistered securities exchange, broker, and clearing agency. Coinbase has been vigorously contesting this allegation.

Earlier in March, Coinbase sued the SEC for crypto rule-making refusal, alleging that the regulatory body had hindered the industry’s development and clarity.

In April, Coinbase submitted document production requests to the SEC, followed by requests in June to SEC Chair Gensler for documents related to communications deemed pertinent to the case. This includes records that cover the period before Gensler assumed office on April 17, 2021.

The SEC, in a letter to the Judge on June 28, opposed Coinbase’s request to search Gensler’s emails. Coinbase sought to determine if Gensler used these emails to express his views on federal securities laws and crypto assets.

The SEC argued that this move would constitute an unwarranted intrusion into a public official’s private affairs, especially given his role in public service. The SEC urged the Court to reject Coinbase’s subpoena and issue a protective order.

As the debate over the relevance of Gensler’s emails continues, both Coinbase and the SEC, along with the broader crypto community, await Judge Katherine Failla’s ruling on the matter.

Coinbase Gathers Support from the Crypto Community

Coinbase’s Chief Legal Officer (CLO) highlighted the importance of their recent legal filing in a post on X.

The CLO stated that it is essential to determine whether Coinbase had sufficient clarity on securities laws and regulations regarding digital assets.

We have responded to @SECGov ‘s effort to block reasonable discovery from Mr. Gensler in a case that it—not Coinbase—chose to file. Democracy, as well as due process, dies in darkness. We appreciate the Court’s careful consideration of this matter. pic.twitter.com/YgXi6lElUX

— paulgrewal.eth (@iampaulgrewal) July 4, 2024

The CLO’s remarks received support from the crypto community and industry figures, including Mike Dudas, co-founder of The Block, a leading platform for crypto news.

Dudas supported Coinbase’s stance, arguing that Gensler’s blending of personal and professional perspectives over his tenure has created ambiguity in cryptocurrency regulation.

Dudas stressed the urgency of individual accountability in addressing these complexities.

Bill Morgan, a respected figure in crypto law circles, responded to the CLO’s statements, pointing out the extensive legal process Ripple underwent to obtain discovery of emails involving William Hinman, which spanned a rigorous two-year period.

It took two years for Ripple to obtain discovery of the Hinman emails. It could also be a long road for @coinbase even though the discovery sought is obviously relevant. https://t.co/1onh4MborJ

— bill morgan (@Belisarius2020) July 4, 2024

Morgan suggested that Coinbase might similarly face a protracted legal journey, despite the evident relevance of the documents sought.