China’s Digital Yuan Still Encounters Challenges in Adoption: Report

China’s digital yuan, the country’s central bank digital currency (CBDC), is facing significant hurdles in gaining widespread adoption. Despite an ambitious rollout that began in 2019, user reluctance and competition from entrenched mobile payment systems like Alipay and WeChat Pay continue to impede progress.

Adoption Challenges for the Digital Yuan

Charles Chang, director of the Fintech Research Centre at Fudan University, explained that “the digital yuan is facing some bottlenecks in adoption today.”

In a recent interview on December 1 with the South China Morning Post, Chang attributed these challenges to the well-established user base of existing platforms, which makes it difficult for consumers to transition to the state-backed currency.

China’s digital yuan program has been gradually expanded, with pilot projects now active in 26 regions across 17 provinces. However, there is still no official timeline for a nationwide rollout, signaling the government’s cautious approach amid these persistent challenges.

It was revealed earlier that the digital yuan project “failed,” citing this as a sign of President Xi Jinping’s “weakening power.”

China faces a choice between allowing the yuan to depreciate in the face of expected tariffs (and risk triggering a negative reaction from Trump that leads to more tariffs) or waiting for the actual imposition of tariffs before allowing the yuan to move.

1/ pic.twitter.com/dUSgeO8k4b

— Brad Setser (@Brad_Setser) November 26, 2024

China’s mobile payment market is currently dominated by Alipay, which Ant Group operates, and Tencent’s WeChat Pay. Together, these platforms handle a significant portion of the country’s digital transactions.

China has approximately 185 licensed non-bank payment institutions, further emphasizing the crowded nature of the digital payments ecosystem.

Competition from Mobile Payment Giants

Even with the digital yuan reaching a cumulative transaction value of 7.3 trillion yuan (approximately $1.02 trillion) as of July 2024, experts remain skeptical about its ability to compete effectively.

Chen Zhiwu, chair professor of finance at the University of Hong Kong, noted that the digital yuan “cannot fundamentally break free from the broader limitations of the yuan’s appeal,” referring to the existing dominance of other payment options and the currency’s limited global reach.

The People’s Bank of China (PBOC) continues to push the digital yuan as part of its efforts to lead in the global CBDC race.

Despite allegations of corruption against Yao Qian, the former head of the PBOC’s digital currency institute, the initiative remains a cornerstone of China’s financial innovation strategy.

However, users’ reluctance to adopt the digital yuan highlights deeper issues. Observers believe the state will focus on incentivizing businesses and consumers to adopt it while addressing key concerns such as privacy and usability.

China’s latest innovation in digital yuan adoption is the introduction of a physical CBDC card featuring dynamic QR codes and offline payment capabilities. First showcased at the 18th Shenzhen International Financial Expo, the card functions like a traditional debit card, supporting tap-to-pay and scan-to-pay options.

In Chinese supermarkets, facial recognition or QR code scan (linked to your CBDC account) now is mandatory for paying your goods. Many places don't accept cash anymore. 🔊

If you are blacklisted by the Social Credit System, your payment will be denied 🚨🚨🚨

This system, if we… pic.twitter.com/x5fxl2kwqa

— Wall Street Mav (@WallStreetMav) August 22, 2023

The slow adoption of the digital yuan reflects broader challenges in the global digital currency space, where a report revealed China as one of the top countries with failed crypto projects and scams.

Alongside the US and the UK, China’s involvement in these issues underscores the complexities of gaining public trust and navigating competitive financial ecosystems, which also impacts the adoption of state-backed innovations like the digital yuan.