ANNA: Making Sense of the SEC's Case Against Telegram
Telegram lost another round in court against the Securities and Exchange Commission and now can’t launch its $1.7 billion token sale. What does it mean for the crypto industry and other startups that sold tokens? Attorneys Philip Moustakis and Gabriel Shapiro are discussing what's next for Telegram and the token industry.
ABOUT
Telegram, the popular messaging app, has big plans for its blockchain Telegram Open Network, or TON. It also had one of the biggest token sales in history, followed by a huge legal fight over it.
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the SEC) sued the company to stop its $1.7 billion private token sale, saying the future tokens for TON, called grams, are unregistered securities. Telegram argued grams were a commodity. A federal court judge in New York issued a preliminary injunction agreeing with the SEC, blocking Telegram from issuing tokens.
The court battle has been an interesting one, as is the ruling of the judge. Together with two experienced attorneys, Gabriel Shapiro of BSV Law and Phillip Moustakis of Seward & Kissel, we’re unpacking this process, which is likely to set a precedent for other token sales structured as SAFT, or simple agreement for future tokens – starting with Kik and potentially followed by many more.
- SAFTs used to be a popular form of fundraising in crypto – What went wrong for Telegram?
- Is there still a chance an ambitious proof-of-stake blockchainhttps://test.ton.org/ will still get launched?
- Is there still a safe way to raise money via a token sale or not?
- What are the remaining options for Telegram – and for its investors?
See also:
Judge Halts Telegram Token Issuance in Injunction Requested by SEC
Telegram Hopes It Can Still Sell Tokens to Non-US Investors After Court Ruling
Blockchain Association Says Court ‘Erred’ With Decision to Block Telegram’s Token Issuance
Digital Chamber Asks Court to Draw Line Between Investment Contracts and Assets in Telegram Case
Andreessen Horowitz: “Reading Between the Lines: SEC, Telegram, and Rule 144”
SEC Settles Securities Registration Charges Against 2 ICO Startups
HOST
CoinDesk is the world leader in news, prices and information on bitcoin and other digital currencies.
We cover news and analysis on the trends, price movements, technologies, companies and people in the bitcoin and digital currency world.

EPISODES
Privacy Is a “Must” for Global Blockchain Adoption in 2026
Unpacking the role of privacy in crypto's future with Pantera Capital Managing Partner Paul Veradittakit and Subzero ...
9 hours ago
Pantera Capital's Top Crypto Predictions for 2026
Pantera Capital's 2026 predictions.
9 hours ago
THE MINING POD: TeraWulf’s $1.3B Raise, Riot’s $500 ATM, SMLR-ASST Merger, Beckham Bends Away from BTC
For today’s roundup, TeraWulf’s Fluidstack JV bags $1.3B and David Beckham’s Prenetics abandons its BTC strategy.
12 hours ago
THE MINING POD: The 2025 Hashies: Introducing Blockspace’s Annual Awards Show
For the final Mining Pod of 2025, we inaugurate The Hashies, Blockspace’s annual award show.
Dec 30, 2025

The Mining Pod
Feb 10, 2025

CoinDesk Podcast Network
The top stories and best shows in the blockchain world, delivered daily from the team at CoinDesk.
Dec 20, 2023

Markets Outlook
Tune in as CoinDesk runs down action in the crypto market and some of the most important recent industry development.
Dec 19, 2023

Unchained
Unchained, your no hype resource for all things crypto by former Forbes senior editor Laura Shin, author of The Cryptopians.
Dec 18, 2023
